Thursday, June 11, 2009

Lament for the Marred Reputation of Good Stories

I lament the denigration of modern storytelling. Be it novels, tv shows, or movies, the legitimate good story is an endangered species. And soon all such media will carry the same expectations.

There are many reasons I find it hard to be satisfied by a story.
  • The saturation of stories in the industry- I don't even know how many movie companies there are these days. And anyone can get published, it seems. It's not just that so many sub-standard stories squeeze through the cracks. It seems more and more that such books and movies and shows are pushed through, as long as they can make some dough. And it doesn't help that no one's coming up with new ideas either. Many good ones would still be left if not ruined by some cheap B-movie.
  • The trade of action for story- I can understand the pull of a good action sequence as much as anyone, I would imagine, but there's got to be a limit. It's not a new demand from viewers/readers that action actually have something to add to the plot, but its just getting ridiculous. Let me reiterate- good action does not make up for a bad plot. It's too bad that the blockbusters thrive on the dime of 14yr olds who willingly settle for cheap thrills.
  • The senseless plot complexity- I don't know if this is a new phenomenon, but its getting to be worse than the action deal. Storytellers are beginning to think they can wow us with the complexity of a plot to the degree that we can't see how illogical it is. Ocean's Elven came close but actually passed brilliantly. Then Pirates 2 and 3 failed miserably and now every CSI (and the like) episode has to grip the viewers with such a deep, twisting plot that can't help but to be resolved poorly. The plots that start out well collapse under their own weight because very few storytellers can conclude well. A 60 minute show now typically contains enough plot to write 3 novels, if handled correctly.
  • The casual handling of potentially major plot features- Not only are plots scrunched and crammed together, they are incredibly devalued. Just one crime or one potential crime could be a good story, if told correctly. Instead, more than 100 people die just in one story of 24, or a cop show runs through 3 possible motives/killers/mysteries before ending on the most unlikely. Each of those could be magnified and enjoyed, standing alone.
At the risk of injuring my own aspirations for writing and/or filmmaking, I am intent on clarifying and raising my standards of acceptable entertainment. It is not good if it doesn't end well (I'm not talking happily-ever-after). Perhaps some of my grades have been to generous. It may not be so in the future. And if, given the opportunity, I write or film, I pray I will not disappoint a viewer or reader like you or myself.

2 comments:

Jessi said...

I completely agree with you, only I'd add one more point:
The move from entertainment to propaganda. Books and movies alike draw you in with what appears to be an intriguing plot but in reality the story line is nothing but an agenda. I read and watch FICTION to be entertained. I fully understand when I indulge in non-fiction, biographies, true stories, documentaries, ect, that I will encounter view points and agendas, but that is where that stuff belongs. You can even write a fictional story to promote an idea, but be responsible enough to tell your potential audience what the story is about! Slipping a viewpoint/idea/agenda subtly into a story is when that viewpoint becomes propaganda, and it doesn't belong in the entertainment industry.

Kyle said...

Well said, sis.